Jump to content

Jim G

LP Member
  • Posts

    118
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Jim G

  1. #1 Today, 09:35 AM

    458 Italia vs McLaren MP4 Blighty - The UK press decides

     

    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------

     

    Today I found 3 new editions of car magazines here in Jersey (Channel Islands) with the long-awaited head-to-head tests of the McLaren and 458.

     

    I was utterly astonished to see the result:

     

     

    458 - McLaren

     

     

    3 - 0

     

    In the UK press! We can be safe to say that the UK is (rightly) proud of McLaren's achievement and I, for one, am convinced that there has been a bias in the UK reviews like you would expect an Italian magazine to have for the Ferrari.

     

    Nonetheless, the 3 magazines (AutoExpress, AutoCar and TopGear) each came to the same conclusion:

     

    The McLaren is the technically superior, and slightly faster car. But it lacks soul. The Ferrari is fun below 60mph, the McLaren needs very high speeds to feel really special. Now I could have told them that before the test, but it is very cool to see 3 reviews come to that same conclusion. All three said the cars were very close in all respects. The TopGear review was fun - they tested on the Isle of Man with the 2011 TT bike race winner, and since there are no speed limits on Isle of Man....

     

    Conclusion for all three: given the choice, the 458 please!

     

    Hats off to Ron for his achievement, but it's not so easy to engineer passion into a car, is it?

     

     

×
×
  • Create New...